Collaboration Bridging Gap Between U.S.-Mexico Migration, Agriculture

May 18, 2006

Editor's note: Photos for this article are available. Contact Candace Pollock at (614) 292-3799 or pollock.58@ag.osu.edu.

MEXICO CITY, Mexico -- With migrant agricultural labor continuing to increase in Ohio, especially in the nursery/landscape and livestock industries, the greatest challenge for growers and producers is how to effectively communicate and work with their new employees.

On the heels of the current immigration debate in the United States, a group of Ohio State University Extension Educators recently traveled to central Mexico to experience, first-hand, rural Mexico and Mexican agriculture and how they relate to Mexican migration in the United States. The purpose of the visit was to help participants better serve their clientele back home.

"The immigration issue is so much in the public view now that we must become better informed and be able to competently discuss the various issues with our clientele," said Don Breece, a farm management specialist at the OSU Extension Center at Lima, who participated in the trip. "Furthermore, there is great potential for Extension educational programs with employers and Mexican workers, as well as areas of research need in human resource management of the Latino work force."

Other participants of the Extension study tour included Claudio Pasian, an OSU Extension horticulturist; Joanne Kick-Raack, OSU Extension program director for the Department of Entomology and the state's pesticide coordinator; Jim Skeeles, OSU Extension Educator for Lorain County; Francisco Espinoza, an OSU Extension Educator with the Agricultural Business Enhancement Center's Ag and Hort Labor Education Program; and David Hansen, director of the Office of International Programs in Agriculture within the College of Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences.

The 10-day trip, which took the participants to such central Mexican locations as Mexico City, Texcoco, Tlaxcala, Cholula, and other agriculturally based communities, was the result of collaborative efforts between Ohio State's Office of International Programs in Agriculture and the Colegio de Postgraduados. The Colegio is Mexico's premiere agricultural institution with a main campus just outside of Mexico City and five branch campuses throughout Mexico. Ohio State's Center for Latin American Studies also contributed to the planning process.

"The purpose of the program was to broaden the participants' perception and understanding of Mexico's rural areas and communities experiencing migration," said tour host Fernando Manzo-Ramos, Extension and adult education specialist for the Colegio. "From our perspective, this tour may help OSU Extension participants better understand the reasons why these young small farmers migrate, their strong cultural and social ties to their families and communities back in Mexico, and the objectives they pursue when they leave their families behind. All this information can become an important asset when OSU Extension designs its programs."

Individuals of Hispanic or Latino origins make up only a sliver of Ohio's population: 1.9 percent of nearly 11.5 million residents, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. But migrant labor, especially in agriculture, is on the rise. Based on the 2004 Ohio Department of Job and Family Services Migrant Agricultural Ombudsman Report, there are 15,782 documented migrants in Ohio's farm labor force. This represents an increase of 500 workers from the year before. The demand for migrant labor is anticipated to grow between 3 percent and 5 percent a year for the next several years. Additionally, it is estimated that between 75,000 and 150,000 unauthorized migrants work in Ohio, based on a national population survey by the Pew Hispanic Center. That number is also likely to grow.

"The future of agriculture and the future of the productivity of U.S. migrant populations can be positively impacted by collaboration between the Colegio and Ohio State," said Manzo-Ramos. "By sharing our experience working in these small communities, creating a bi-national program in Extension, education and rural development, and using the migration process and the transnational communities it generates, we can help agricultural and rural communities in both countries improve."

From learning about Mexican history to understanding the idea of "community" in Mexican societies; from witnessing the challenges faced by farmers to experiencing the direct impacts of migration on rural communities, the Extension study tour was an eye-opening experience for all those involved.

For Claudio Pasian, knowledge gained during the tour will help reinforce training programs directed toward growers in the nursery industry.

"What I learned on the trip just validated the information I use to help nursery growers better work with their migrant labor force," said Pasian, who also holds a partial research appointment with the Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center. "Now that I have an even better understanding of Mexican social organizations, I can provide even more useful information to those seeking to improve their working relationships." Pasian also plans to launch teaching seminars based on information gleaned from the tour for students entering the horticulture industry.

The trip was a life-changing experience for Jim Skeeles.

"I've learned that we need to have more respect and more acceptance of those from other countries and of different socioeconomic status, rather than trying to impose American morals and values on them and their situation," he said.

Skeeles hopes to use what he's learned from the trip to develop programs aimed at diminishing the initial trauma of across-border work experiences, assisting U.S. employers to improve their working relationships with the migrant labor force, and preparing migrants before entering the United States.

"We have similar program goals and share similar development agendas. Our countries are tied together and depend on each other," said Manzo-Ramos. "That is why the working relationship we are trying to develop is so important and necessary."

The Extension study tour has been one the most extensive and intensive collaboration efforts between the Colegio and Ohio State. The project builds on collaborative efforts that began during the 1990s when CFAES administration, including Dean Bobby Moser, OSU Extension Director Keith Smith, and Dave Hansen consolidated the partnership between the two institutions.

But if all parties involved have their way, this trip won't be their last. Efforts are already under way to host representatives of the Colegio in Ohio, with special emphasis on the nursery, landscaping, poultry and dairy industries. The potential also exists to conduct a similar Extension study tour in Mexico next year.

"The similarities between our two countries were more striking to me than the differences," said Breece. "Agriculture truly is a universal language."

Author(s): 
Candace Pollock
Source(s): 
Claudio Pasian, David Hansen, Don Breece, Fernando Manzo-Ramos, Jim Skeeles